So Hayley Cropper gave herself the chop in last night's episode of Coronation Street and I have to say that I think this storyline was misguided and heartless from start to finish.
Okay so I know pancreatic cancer is a horrible disease and research into its treatment is woefully underfunded. I also know that there is a body of opinion which says that putting it on the forefront of a soap plot is a good way of "raising awareness". And I also know that a television soap is supposed, almost by definition, to be family entertainment. It's what we pay our licence fees for and why we put up with ever increasing amounts of cretinous adverts. So I sincerely question whether it is justifiable or fair to use television for this kind of purpose when we are constantly bombarded by junk mail and our progress upon the high street is impeded by continual demands for our awareness concerning one cause or another. Anyhow isn't it really more the province of one-off dramas? And furthermore any television programme which requires the setting up of a "help line" has lost it's right to be called entertainment of any but the most sensationlist and voyeuristic kind.
I have also got to say that the role Hayley Cropper was never one of Coronation Street's deftest bits of casting. This is no slur on Julie Hesmondhalgh's acting. But I have always wondered what part of gender reassignment treatment is used give a man the ditzy character and posture of a finnicky and nasally challenged middleaged woman. What I mean is that Julie was never a convincing transsexual. And so her marriage to Roy was also unconvincing. So far as I have seen it does not matter how medically proficient or expensive the reassignment procedures are, they never completely succeed in creating a totally passable female. And Julie Hesmondhalgh as Hayley Cropper was certainly that.
All in all I'm glad she's gone bringing to an end that particular vein of misery. I am also glad that the suggested storyline of Roy assisting in her suicide did not transpire as that would simply have dragged the story out well beyond human endurance.
I will end by saying that I am sure I am not the only one to have lost a loved one and who found the whole story a completely unnecessary and distressing reminder.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments will be moderated